The argument of manual vs automatic cars has been ongoing since 1939, when the first automatic model came out. Both sides make valid points, which are both factual and subjective. If you are considering a new car, and are confused whether to get a manual or automatic or are curious as to how they work, you've come to the right place. In this blog, we cover how manual and automatic transmissions work and their pros and cons.

Automatic vs Manual Cars- Pros And Cons

Before we get into automatic car vs manual car, let's have a quick overview of how a transmission works.

What is a transmission?

A transmission is an important part of an automobile system, which connects the engine to the wheels. This system handles the torque and power delivery to the wheels. The gears in a transmission system alter the torque delivered to the wheels. Some automatic transmissions use a belt and pulley system instead of stationary gears.

An ICE engine can only produce a limited amount of torque. In most cases, it won't be enough to move the vehicle. This is where a transmission helps. When at lower gears, the transmission produces more torque at the cost of reduced speed. This low torque allows the car to overcome the force of inertia. Higher gears, on the other hand, increase speed at the cost of torque. The act of changing gears necessitates a device to separate the colliding gears. This is where a clutch comes in.

The clutch disconnects the engine from the transmission, which allows the driver to shift gears.

There are two major types of transmission, manual and automatic. The driver controls the clutch in a manual transmission, while in an automatic system it's handled on its own.

Also Check Out: Hatchback Vs Sedan Vs SUV- Which One Should You Buy?

Manual Transmission

A manual transmission requires pressing the clutch to change gears. Without making this too complex, a clutch stops the connection between the engine and the transmission. The process of changing gear in a manual transmission is done in 3 steps

• Press the clutch pedal
• Change gear
• Release the clutch pedal

While it's easier when written down, manual transmissions have a steep learning curve. Releasing the clutch pedal too quickly at lower gears will cause your vehicle to stall. Learning when to let go of the clutch pedal is the biggest hurdle in operating a manual transmission.

Automatic Transmission

An automatic transmission removes the process of holding pressing on the clutch. The transmission system takes care of this process on its own, hence the name. There are multiple types of automatic transmission, each with its pros and cons, which are as follows:

Which One To Choose?

With the basic understanding of both systems out of the way, let's compare them to see which is a better choice depending on the following criteria:

Fuel Efficiency

In the olden days, opting for the convenience of a manual transmission meant sacrificing mileage. It's not the case anymore, with automatic on par with manuals and sometimes even better. Modern automatics are more advanced and fine-tuned to offer performance and fuel efficiency.

Ease Of Driving

Automatic cars are easier to drive than manual cars. No clutch and gearbox to manage makes the automatic car a piece of cake to operate. This is especially true in the case of heavy traffic, where driving a manual car takes incredible effort compared to an automatic car.

Fun To Drive

While this point is subjective, most driving enthusiasts prefer a manual over an automatic car. Manual transmission cars allow better control over the transmission system, making the drive a more involved affair. While some models offer paddle shifters, they still can't recreate the experience of driving a manual transmission.

Cost

Automatic cars cost a significant premium over the manual transmission. Automatic transmissions have more moving parts when compared to a manual, making them costlier to fix. They are also more complex than a manual system, further adding to the cost of repair and maintenance.

Reliability

Manual transmissions are generally more reliable than their counterparts owing to their simple design. An automatic transmission is made up of more advanced technology, which involves sensors and computers. These parts are more susceptible to damage when compared to a manual transmission. Do note that bad driving habits can destroy either transmission.

Performance

While a manual offers more control, it cannot offer better performance than an automatic system. A DCT automatic system can adjust gear ratios at rates impossible for even a highly trained human. As such, automatic transmissions are better if you want a high-performance car.

Automatic Or Manual? Conclusion

When it comes to manual vs automatic transmission, the choice depends on your needs. If a car is just a tool for you to take you from one place to another, opt for an automatic transmission. The ease of driving an automatic, especially in heavy traffic, cannot be matched by a manual transmission. An automatic transmission car will cost more than a manual option and will be costlier to maintain.

If you want more control over your vehicle, choose a type of car that has a manual transmission. Although they have a higher skill ceiling than an automatic, they are fun to drive, engaging and affordable than their counterpart. All this comes at the cost of a painful driving experience during heavy traffic.

Also Read: Top 10 Cars for First-Time Buyers in India - Updated List